Home
the-dark-batpup-returns
Eric TF Bat's Journal
It's People Like You What Causes Unrest
Cranky Symmetry 
12th-May-2008 04:59 pm
this-isnt-real
Wading through the glorious textual sewer lovingly tended by the dunnikin divers of Crank Dot Net, I found this particularly cranky site, The Official Geocentricity Website.
At that time Nicolaus Copernicus (picture below), a Polish canon who dabbled in astrology, claimed that the sun and not the earth was at the center of the universe. His idea is known as heliocentrism. It took a hundred years for heliocentrism to become the dominant opinion, and it did so with a complete lack of evidence in its favor.

It's amusing stuff, but what's really telling is how similar these arguments and explanations are to the people who rave on about the impossibility of human-caused global warming. All the same smears, smarms and outright lies that we see in the Crankiest biblical websites are regurgitated, cut and pasted, by the people who want us to think that global warming is just a conspiracy in which hundreds of thousands of scientists of widely differing origins have all gotten together to create a grand coordinated lie without leaving any meeting minutes or incriminating emails behind as evidence.
Comments 
12th-May-2008 11:32 am (UTC)
Oooh! I thought that it was going to be a joke site, a-la most nominal flat-earth-ists, or last-thursdayists, or tea-pottists, or Rush Limbaugh supporters.

Then I saw the biblical bit! Hee!
12th-May-2008 05:11 pm (UTC) - OK I'll bite
At the time, Copernicus' theory was justly reviled because it was (a) messy and complex, and unnecessarily so
(b) unscientific in the extreme/.

Why (b)? Because the only way we could accept it was by saying OK there IS stellar parallax but it's too small to see.

Maybe someone should however tell these guys that after Johannes Kepler, however, it's now time to admit that we have got a goer here and it looks like Mr Sun's in the middle after all. Ooooh look! An ellipse!
13th-May-2008 07:22 am (UTC) - Re: OK I'll bite
Simon Singh in Big Bang made the point that part of Nicky's problem was that he was a grumpy old bugger with the charisma of cat poo and a habit of offending everyone within three parsecs just by breathing funny... so he had a little trouble getting his message across.

But the previous best guess as to the movement of the planets involved seriously complex mathematics (all the stuff about epicycles and the rest) whereas Copernicus's alternative explanation simplified things remarkably. His problem was that the maths to describe ellipses didn't exist yet, so he had to claim it was circles and the error was all experimental.
13th-May-2008 04:15 am (UTC)
"It took a hundred years for heliocentrism to become the dominant opinion, and it did so with a complete lack of evidence in its favor."

They didn't finish that sentence. It should have ended "...except for the mountains of it which we've chosen not to believe in because it contradicts our ideology."
13th-May-2008 06:33 am (UTC)
Yep, just like creationists and global-warming deniers.
13th-May-2008 11:02 am (UTC)
Precisely :)
This page was loaded Oct 6th 2008, 8:49 pm GMT.