Been thinking about this one for a while. This is a post -- a rant, maybe -- about parenting, so I'm prepared for the very real possibility that I'll be offending some of my readership. Therefore, let me start by laying my cards on the table: I think you're
all appallingly bad parents, every one of you, and your children are hideously deformed meat beasts...
except for a few of you, who are excellent and have stunningly gorgeous Small People. But the rest? Osamas bin Laden infested with tiny Gollums, the lot of 'em. So feel free to
be offended; it's your right.
Now, with that disclaimer out of the way, on with the rant.
A friend of mine posted a while back that she strongly dislikes parents who don't spank their children. My first reaction was probably unprintable, although it had Darwinian aspects to it, ie "feel free to do whatever you like to disadvantage your kids; it'll give mine a leg up in the coming Apocalypse". But then I remembered how I used to titter at the freakazoid hippy parents I knew in my ill-spent and frequently-wallopped youth, the ones who couldn't bear to so much as raise their squeaky voices as their snotty offspring ran roughshod over them. Not giving your kids a good thumping every now and then, it seemed pretty clear to my ten-year-old mind, was a good way to produce feral lunatics; BAD idea. And after all, I got my share of whacks with the cane, the belt or the back of my Dad's hand, and I'm no worse off for it (apart from the twitching and the nightmares and the brain damage, but I lived in Albury in the 1970s so I know what to blame for those). Seriously: it wasn't a problem for me, then.
But opinions change. For example, I used to think the Windows 95 UI looked pretty schmick, and now... not so much. We don't hit our kids -- well, not when we're in our right minds -- and we feel strongly that it would be the Wrong Thing to do so under any circumstances. Even an ear tweak is right out, thought admittedly I had to have that explained in very loud and unambiguous monosyllables after the first and last time I delivered one to the Elder Daughter of DOOOM, because it hadn't occurred to me that it might be a problem. But I know better now. Anyway.
I had to think for a long time about
why hitting is bad, especially considering that a fair amount of
shouting is par for the course around here when the EDoD is being the Entitlement Queen of Hell and I'm tired and shagged out after a long day's Javascripting. And the best I can come up with is this:
I don't hit my children for exactly the same reason I don't hit my wife.
That's pretty much it.
I've mentioned before that I dislike using the word "children" in reference to my own family members, even though it never bothered me to be called a child back when I was one. Ageism is the last great legal discrimination, sticking around when even Atheists are starting to demand equal rites, and I'm acutely aware of how much of it my 11-going-on-22-year-old daughter has to put up with. Adults will quite happily ignore her when she speaks to them, even when her grammar and vocabulary are clearly superior to theirs (which is about two thirds of the time, even in "elitist" Canberra) and there are a whole bunch of things she is physically and emotionally capable of that the law or convention says she can't do, like travelling on a plane alone or making her own purchases without parental supervision. She's a vassal, basically, and it irritates her, and by osmosis me too.
So the ideal I work from is that she deserves the same rights and respect that I'd afford an adult. Admittedly, she's more like a drunk and disorderly adult at times, because at age 11 she's not always completely rational or informed, but coming back to that point I made above: I wouldn't hit my wife, even if she were drunk and irrational, so why should I hit my daughter? It's a change in viewpoint, a different way of looking at the world. Once you see it like that, you need some fairly heavy-duty self-deception to continue waling away at your kids. Slap your kids for disobedience? Fine, then do it your spouse too. Otherwise, not so much.
The difficulty is that kids who get spanked are more easily controlled, and since we treat our Small People with respect they don't always technically earn, there are times when they get the better end of the deal and we get the worse. That means we have to compensate: we spend much more time reasoning with the EDoD and the Batpup than we would if we could just hurt them to make them compliant. Often, this doesn't work, and it's a rare week when I don't feel like introducing Ms EDoD to Mr Fist. But I don't.
It would be wrong.Along with that, there's the emotional component: I want to hit her, when I'm angry at her,
because it would feel good. That is so utterly the wrong reason that I'm not even going to dignify it with more paragraph.
Life is made trickier by her absurdly high intelligence, but considerably easier by her
emotional intelligence: she has approximately the same ability to compose herself and reign in her emotions as I has developed by about age 25; she is quite, quite remarkable, and I wish I could film her doing it because you'd be astonished, even those rare ones of you with the good quality munchkins. If she and I are arguing, it usually turns out that she's right and I'm wrong, so I have learned stupid amounts of humility. But when she's wrong and she realises it, she's better than me (and most people I know) at switching her ego into neutral and, if not quite admitting it, certainly removing the self-righteousness from her emotional makeup and letting herself calm right down.
So what we have is neither the cowed, defeated, often-spanked extreme, nor the undisciplined hippy egomaniac opposite extreme, but something else, right off the continuum: an Elder Daughter who responds (eventually) to reason, will not allow her emotions to override her brain for too long, and who is better equipped for adulthood than I was when I was twice her age. And her younger brother and sister, growing up with the benefit of our hindsight and experimentation, will no doubt be even more stable and well-prepared. This, I think, makes the occasional screaming fits worth it, and means I'm not going to be splashing out and buying any extra bullwhips and cats-o'-nine-tails any time soon.
So: non-spanking parent, and proud of it. Other parents are entitled to their own views, but I know we're right about this one.